• Home
  • Boon Box Drill
  • Boon Mini Hopper
  • Boon Tyre Roller
  • Knowledge Hub
  • FAQ
  • Innovation
    • Innovation
    • Smarter Sponge System
    • Modular Metering System
    • S-Tines
    • Ram spacers
    • Hydraulic Ram System
    • Harrows
    • Electronics
  • More
    • Home
    • Boon Box Drill
    • Boon Mini Hopper
    • Boon Tyre Roller
    • Knowledge Hub
    • FAQ
    • Innovation
      • Innovation
      • Smarter Sponge System
      • Modular Metering System
      • S-Tines
      • Ram spacers
      • Hydraulic Ram System
      • Harrows
      • Electronics

  • Home
  • Boon Box Drill
  • Boon Mini Hopper
  • Boon Tyre Roller
  • Knowledge Hub
  • FAQ
  • Innovation
    • Innovation
    • Smarter Sponge System
    • Modular Metering System
    • S-Tines
    • Ram spacers
    • Hydraulic Ram System
    • Harrows
    • Electronics
Tractor working on a farm field at sunset.

Choosing the Right Seed Drill

 Disc or tine? Direct drilling or conventional cultivation? Here's everything you need to know before investing in your next seed drill. 

Buying a seed drill isn't simple

It's choosing the right tool for your soils, your farming system, your crops, and the way you like to work.

Every farm is different.


Rolling hill country behaves differently from irrigated plains.


Heavy clay responds differently to light free-draining soils.


Pasture renewal requires different considerations than cereal establishment.


This guide explains the key differences between today's most common drilling systems, when each one performs best, and why many New Zealand farmers continue to choose tine drills for their versatility, reliability and consistent performance.


Whether you're replacing an existing drill or buying your first machine, we'll help you understand what really matters.


 Understanding What a Seed Drill Actually Does 

 

Before comparing machines, it's worth understanding the job they're designed to perform.

Every seed drill has one purpose:

Place every seed at the correct depth, with good seed-to-soil contact, in the right environment for germination.


That sounds simple.

In reality, it requires every component of the drill to work together.


The opener creates the seed trench.


The metering system controls seed placement.


The harrows finish the job.


If one part doesn't perform properly, crop establishment can suffer.


Good engineering isn't about adding complexity.


It's about making every stage of the drilling process work consistently across varying paddock conditions.


The Two Main Types of Seed Drill 

 

Most modern seed drills fall into two broad categories:

  • Disc seed drills 
  • Tine seed drills 


Both achieve the same outcome.


They simply go about it differently.


What Is a Disc Seed Drill? 


A disc drill uses rotating steel discs to slice through the soil, creating a narrow slot where seed is placed before the slot is closed.


Because the discs cut rather than lift the soil, disc drills create very little soil disturbance.


This makes them popular for direct drilling and minimum tillage systems where preserving surface residue is important.


Advantages

  • Minimal soil disturbance 
  • Excellent in heavy crop residue 
  • Suitable for direct drilling 
  • Helps maintain ground cover 
  • Can reduce erosion 


Considerations

  • More moving parts and wearing components 
  • Can be more expensive to maintain 
  • Sticky soils may affect performance 
  • Hairpinning can occur if residue isn't cut cleanly 
  • Often higher initial purchase cost 

What Is a Tine Seed Drill?

Rather than cutting through the soil with discs, a tine drill opens the soil using robust steel tines.

This gently fractures the ground before placing seed into the seedbed.

 

For many New Zealand farming systems, particularly cultivated paddocks and pasture renewal, this remains an extremely practical and effective approach.

Rather than cutting through the soil with discs, a tine drill opens the soil using robust steel tines.

vantages

  • Excellent seed-to-soil contact 
  • Simple, robust engineering 
  • Lower maintenance requirements 
  • Handles uneven terrain well 
  • Well suited to cultivated seedbeds 
  • Performs well in stony conditions 


Considerations

  • Greater soil disturbance than discs 
  • Less suited to some no-till systems 
  • May bring more weed seed to the surface


 

Not All Tine Drills Are the Same


When we talk about a tine seed drill, there's another important distinction to make.


The type of tine matters.

Different tine designs behave differently as they move through the soil, affecting soil movement, trash clearance, seedbed preparation and ultimately how the drill performs in different conditions.

Two common approaches are the S-tine and the coil tine.


S-Tine Seed Drills

An S-tine isn't simply a rigid piece of steel being pulled through the ground.

Its distinctive shape allows the tine to flex and vibrate as it travels through the soil. This creates a light cultivating action directly around the row as the seed is being placed.


Rather than simply opening a path for the seed, that movement can help create tilth around the seed row, preparing the immediate seedbed as you drill.


Where does an S-tine perform well?


An S-tine system can be particularly effective when you want:

  • A light cultivating action while drilling
  • Good tilth around the seed row
  • Effective seedbed preparation and seed placement in one pass
  • A tine that can respond to changing ground conditions
  • Good clearance through crop residue and trash
  • A versatile drill for typical New Zealand conditions


That combination of movement and soil preparation is one of the reasons S-tine drills have been so successful in New Zealand farming.


Coil Tine Seed Drills


A coil tine takes a different approach.


The coil provides some flexibility, but the tine is generally more rigid in operation than an S-tine and doesn't produce the same degree of vibration through the soil.


It still opens the ground effectively for seed placement, but with less of the cultivating action associated with an S-tine.


Where can a coil tine work well?


A coil tine can be a good option where:

  • A firmer, more controlled opener action is preferred
  • Less movement of the tine is desirable
  • The seedbed has already been well prepared
  • Conditions don't require as much cultivating action around the seed row


Both systems have their place. The important difference is understanding what happens below the surface as you drill.


Why Boon Uses the S-Tine Approach


For us, the benefits of an S-tine made sense.

But we didn't stop at simply fitting a conventional S-tine.


Boon's S-tine has been developed to be stronger and shaped to provide excellent trash clearance, while retaining the flexing and vibrating action that makes the S-tine concept so effective.


That means the tine can work the soil around the seed row while allowing residue and trash to move through the drill more effectively.


The result is a system designed around what actually happens in a New Zealand paddock:


Flex. Vibrate. Create tilth. Place the seed. Keep the trash moving.


It's another example of a simple idea that becomes much more effective when the engineering behind it is properly thought through.

Disc vs Tine Seed Drills

Which Drill Suits Your Farm?


This is the question every farmer eventually asks.


The answer depends less on the machine and more on how you farm.


A disc drill may suit you if:

  • You primarily direct drill. 
  • You work in heavy crop residues. 
  • Maintaining maximum ground cover is a priority. 
  • You operate a minimum tillage system. 


A tine drill may suit you if:

  • You regularly cultivate before drilling. 
  • You renovate pasture. 
  • You farm varied New Zealand terrain. 
  • You value simple, dependable engineering. 
  • You want lower ongoing maintenance. 
  • You need versatility across different farming applications. 


Direct Drilling Explained


Direct drilling involves placing seed into existing ground without prior cultivation.


The aim is to minimise soil disturbance while preserving soil structure, retaining moisture, reducing erosion and leaving crop residue on the surface.


Disc drills are commonly associated with direct drilling because they slice cleanly through residue with minimal disturbance.


However, certain tine drills can also be used successfully in direct drilling situations depending on soil conditions, residue levels and machine design.


The right choice depends on your farming system rather than a single drilling method.


Minimum Till vs Conventional Cultivation


Minimum tillage reduces the amount of cultivation before planting.


Conventional cultivation prepares the seedbed through one or more cultivation passes before drilling.

Neither approach is universally better.


Both have advantages depending on soil type, climate, crop rotation, residue management and farm objectives.


The important consideration is selecting a drill designed to perform well within your chosen system.


Why Many New Zealand Farmers Continue to Choose Tine Drills


There is a reason tine drills remain widely used across New Zealand.


They are simple.


Reliable.


Easy to maintain.


And well suited to the diverse conditions found across the country.


From rolling hill country to cultivated plains, a well-designed tine drill provides consistent seed placement, dependable performance and straightforward operation.


Good engineering isn't always about adding more technology.


Sometimes it's about solving problems before they occur.


Why Harrows Matter More Than Most People Realise


Once the seed has been placed, the harrows complete the final stage of the drilling process.


They level the soil.


Cover the seed.


Help create consistent seed-to-soil contact.


Yet this critical component is often overlooked.


At Boon, we believe the finish matters just as much as the opening pass.


That's why we've developed our patented harrow system to move naturally with the ground, reduce stress on the machine and produce a consistent finish across varying paddock conditions. 


Ready to Find the Right Seed Drill?


Every farm is different, and the  best drill is the one that suits your land, your farming system and your goals.


If you'd like to discuss which Boon drill is right for your operation, our team is here to help.


Whether you're establishing pasture, drilling crops or upgrading your existing equipment, we can help you choose a machine built for New Zealand conditions.


Talk to the Boon team today.

Disc vs Tine Frequently Asked Questions

Please reach us at Andrew@boon.ag if you cannot find an answer to your question.

 

A disc drill is well suited to trashy ground conditions because the discs cut through crop residue, long grass and other surface material rather than allowing it to build up around the drill. Some tyne drills can also be fitted with a row of cutting discs at the front to help slice through heavy trash before the tynes pass through.

Another key difference is how the drills handle stony ground. Disc drills tend to ride over stones and rocks, while tynes can pull or “pluck” them to the surface. Where this occurs, farmers may need to heavy-roll the paddock afterwards to push exposed stones back down, helping create a safer surface for stock and reducing the risk of injury to animals’ feet.


 

This often comes down to personal preference and the result you want to achieve. A disc drill generally creates a tidier, lower-disturbance finish because the discs slice through the existing pasture rather than pulling or tearing at it. This can make it a good option where preserving existing grass is important.

A tyne drill fitted with sharp tips can also work effectively through existing pasture, but it creates more soil movement. For some farmers, this is an advantage because the tynes create tilth around the seed, helping form a cultivated seedbed and supporting good seed-to-soil contact.

Ultimately, the choice depends on whether you prioritise minimal disturbance to existing pasture or the additional tilth and soil movement created by a tyne drill.


Generally, tine drills are considerably cheaper and simpler to maintain. While disc drills have the advantage of riding over rocks rather than pulling them to the surface, repeated contact with stones can still damage discs and place additional stress on bearings.

Disc drills also have more wearing and moving components, which can make maintenance more expensive and time-consuming. By comparison, the simpler design of a tine drill typically means fewer components to maintain and replace, helping keep ongoing maintenance costs down.


A well-designed, heavy-duty tine drill can perform particularly well in hard ground conditions. A drill with the right tip angle and strong spring tyne design, such as the Boon Agriculture drill, can achieve good penetration for direct drilling without requiring excessive machine weight.

By comparison, disc drills rely more heavily on downward weight to achieve penetration in hard, compacted soils. In tougher conditions, some disc drills therefore need to be considerably heavier, which can also require a larger, higher-horsepower tractor to operate effectively.


 Both disc and tine drills have advantages in rocky ground, so the best choice often comes down to farmer preference.

A disc drill is less likely to pull stones to the surface, instead tending to ride over them. However, this can affect consistent seed depth, and frequent contact with rocks can increase wear and damage to discs and bearings, making maintenance more expensive.

A tine drill is more likely to pluck stones from the ground, which may mean the paddock needs heavy rolling afterwards. However, tine drills are generally simpler and less expensive to maintain in rocky conditions.

When considering penetration, seed placement, maintenance and overall running costs, a tine drill can offer advantages in rocky ground, although individual farmers may prioritise these factors differently.


 

Both disc and tine drills can achieve good establishment, but they create quite different seedbed conditions. A tine drill generally creates more tilth, as the tine moves and loosens the soil around the seed during drilling, helping create good seed-to-soil contact.

A disc drill creates less soil disturbance, tending to cut a narrow slot into the ground and place the seed within it. This can be an advantage where minimal disturbance is preferred, while a tine drill may be better suited where creating additional tilth around the seed is desirable.


 

Harrows play an important role after the seed has been placed, helping move and spread soil back over the seed and close the drill lines or slots.

This helps cover and protect the seed from birds, while also improving seed-to-soil contact so the seed has better access to the moisture it needs for germination and establishment. Good soil coverage behind the drill helps create the conditions for more consistent growth.


There are many factors that can affect successful seed establishment, and it isn’t always down to the drill itself. Common causes include incorrect sowing depth, poor moisture levels, inadequate seed-to-soil contact, slugs and other insect pests, and insufficient or imbalanced nutrients.

Soil conditions are also important. Incorrect pH - whether the soil is too acidic or too alkaline - and other soil fertility imbalances can restrict germination and early plant growth. Getting the drilling conditions, seed placement and soil health right all contribute to achieving strong, even establishment.


Tines can bend when they are placed under excessive load or pressure during operation. This can happen when drilling on steep or undulating ground, particularly when travelling uphill, or when the drill is reversed while the tines are still engaged in the soil.

A strong tine design and correct operating technique can help reduce the risk of bending and unnecessary downtime.


 An Anti Roll-Back System is the spring that helps hold the harrows in their correct working position while still allowing them to move when needed. If the drill is reversing, or the harrows snag, catch on something or roll backwards, they can move within their slots rather than being forced against the obstruction.

Once the pressure is released, the spring pulls the harrows back into the correct working position, helping protect the harrow assembly from damage and allowing it to continue operating properly.


 Getting the right seed depth is critical for successful establishment, and the ideal depth varies depending on the type of seed, soil conditions, moisture and weather.

If seed is planted too deep, the emerging plant may run out of energy before it reaches the surface, resulting in poor or failed establishment. Consistent depth also helps ensure the crop emerges and develops at a similar rate across the paddock.

For crops such as fodder beet, this can be particularly important because spraying is often timed to a specific stage of plant development. If seed depth varies, plants can emerge and grow at different rates, meaning some may be too young or vulnerable when spraying occurs.

Seed depth may also be adjusted depending on available soil moisture and expected weather conditions, helping give the seed the best possible environment for germination and early growth.


 There is no set replacement interval for disc openers, as their lifespan depends heavily on ground conditions, soil type, operating speed and the amount of rock or abrasive material they encounter.

Disc openers naturally reduce in diameter as they wear and should be checked regularly for wear, damage and their ability to maintain consistent seed depth. Rocky or abrasive conditions can accelerate wear and may also put additional strain on bearings. Manufacturers generally recommend replacing discs once they reach their specified minimum diameter, become damaged or can no longer maintain correct operation and seed placement.


  • Boon Box Drill
  • Boon Mini Hopper
  • Boon Tyre Roller
  • Knowledge Hub
  • FAQ
  • Electronics

Copyright © 2026 Boon Agriculture - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept